Reconhecimento e Execução de Sentenças Estrangeiras: análise do projeto em andamento na Conferência da Haia de Direito Internacional Privado

Nadia De Araujo, Fabricio B. Pasquot Polido

Resumo


O presente artigo busca analisar a recente evolução dos trabalhos sobre jurisdição internacional e reconhecimento e execução de sentenças estrangeiras (Judgments Project) desenvolvidos pela Conferência da Haia de Direito Internacional Privado, organização internacional que se dedica a elaborar normas para a unificação progressiva dessa área do direito entre seus Membros. Nos últimos quatro anos, um grupo de especialistas e acadêmicos de várias universidades e centros de pesquisa brasileiros - Grupo de Sentenças Estrangeiras (GSE) - tem se reunido periodicamente no Rio de Janeiro para discutir os itens da agenda da Reunião do Conselho de Assuntos Gerais da Conferência, objetivando contribuir para o avanço dos trabalhos da organização em torno da possível elaboração e adoção de uma convenção multilateral em matéria de reconhecimento e execução de sentenças estrangeiras. Como metodologia de análise, além de identificar as principais questões pendentes, o GSE vem formulando conclusões e recomendações de modo a reiterar a posição acadêmica dos especialistas brasileiros a respeito do Projeto de Sentenças Estrangeiras na Conferência. Iniciativas da academia e sociedade civil, cujos resultados se verificam nas reuniões descritas, são fator de mobilização em torno do debate de questões do direito internacional privado em importante foro multilateral, que é a Conferência da Haia de Direito Internacional Privado.

Texto completo:

PDF

Referências


ASADIP. Informe borrador sobre las discusiones del trabajo

de la Conferencia de La Haya de Derecho Internacional

Privado. Jornadas ASADIP 2011, 25 de noviembre de

Disponível em: < http://asadip.files.wordpress.

com/2011/12/asadipcrreport-s.pdf>.

BEAUMONT, Paul. Hague Choice of Court

Agreements Convention 2005: Background,

Negotiations, Analysis and Current Status. Journal of

Private International Law, v. 5, n. 1, p. 125-134, 2009.

HARTLEY, Trevor C. Choice-of-court agreements under

the European and international instruments: the revised

Brussels I Regulation, the Lugano Convention and

the Hague Convention. Oxford, New York: Oxford

Univ. Press, 2013.

HCCH. Conclusions of the Working Group meeting on

enforcement of judgments. Prel. Doc. n. 19 of November

in Proceedings of the Seventeenth Session

(1993), Vol I, 257. Disponível em: < http://www.hcch.

net/upload/wop/jdgm_concl1992e.pdf> .

HCCH. Recognition and Enforcement of foreign civil protection

orders. Permanent Bureau, Report of the Meeting of

The Expert Group, Prel. Doc. n. 4, 12-13 February,

HCCH. Work Programme resulting from the conclusions and

recommendation adopted by the conclusion and recommendation

adopted by the recent special Commission Meetings on the

Practical Operation of the Legal- Cooperation Convention and

Status of Implementation. Permanent Bureau. Prel. Doc. n.

, March 2014.

HCCH. Accessing the content of foreign law and the need for the

development of a global instrument in this area: a possible way

ahead. Prel. Doc. n. 11A of March 2009. Disponível em:

listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Accessing the content of foreign law. Compilation

of responses to the Questionnaire of October 2008

for the meeting of experts on global co-operation on

the provision of online legal information on national

laws. Prel. Doc. n. 11C of March 2009. Disponível em:

listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Accessing the content of foreign law. Report of the

meeting of experts on global co-operation on the

provision of online legal information on national

laws. Prel. Doc. n. 11B of March 2009. Disponível em:

listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Conclusions and recommendations adopted by the

Council. Council on General Affairs and Policy of the

Conference. 9-11 April 2013. Disponível em:

www.hcch.net/upload/wop/gap2013concl_e.pdf>.

HCCH. Conclusions of the Working Group Meeting on

Enforcement of Judgments. Prel. Doc. n. 19 of November

, in Proceedings of the Seventeenth Session, v. 1, p. 257,

HCCH. Continuation of the Judgments Project. Doc. Prel.

of February 2010.HCCH.Ongoing work on judgments

– Choice of Court Convention and Judgments Project. Prel.

Doc. n. 7, February 2014.HCCH. Report of the Second

Meeting of the Working Group of the Judgements Project.

February 2014.

HCCH. Issues Paper on Matters of Jurisdiction (including

Parallel Proceedings). Issues Paper, of January 2013.

Disponível em:

hidden/2013/jdgm2013note02en.pdf>.

HCCH. Conclusions and Recommendations of the Expert

Group on Possible Future Work on Cross-border Litigation in

Civil and Commercial Matters. Work Doc. n. 2 of April

Disponível em:

gaf2012wd2e.pdf>.

HCCH. Note on forms for the recognition and enforcement

of foreign judgments. Prepared by Elizabeth Meurling. Prel.

Doc. n. 30, of June 2005. Disponível em:

www.hcch.net/upload/wop/jdgm_pd30e.pdf>.

HCCH. Ongoing work on international litigation and

possible continuation of the Judgments Project. Prel. Doc. n.

of March 2012. Disponível em

net/index_en.php?act=progress.listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Ongoing work on international litigation and possible

continuation of the Judgments Project. Prel. Doc. n. 5, of

March 2012. Disponível em:

upload/wop/gap12pd05e.pdf>.

HCCH. Ongoing work on international litigation. Prel.

Doc. n. 3, of March 2013. Disponível em:

www.hcch.net/upload/wop/genaff2013pd03e.pdf>.

HCCH. Planning for the sixth meeting of the Special Commission

to review the practical operation of the Hague Convention of

October 1980 on the Civil Aspects of International Child

Abduction and the Hague Convention of 19 October 1996

on Jurisdiction, Applicable Law, Recognition, Enforcement

and Co-operation in respect of Parental Responsibility and

Measures for the Protection of Children. Prel. Doc. n. 14

of February 2011. Disponível em

net/index_en.php?act=progress.listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Preliminary Draft Convention on Jurisdiction and

foreign judgments in civil and commercial matters. Report by

Peter Nygh and Fausto Pocar. Prel. Doc. n. 11, of August

Disponível em

wop/jdgmpd11.pdf >.

HCCH. Process Paper on the Continuation of the Judgments

Project: drawn up by the Permanent Bureau. August

Disponível em:

wop/jdgm2013processpaper_e.pdf >.

HCCH. Questionnaire and Recognition and Enforcement

of Foreign Civil Protection Orders. Prel. Doc. n. 4A, of

November 2012. Disponível em:

net/index_en.php?act=progress.listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Questionnaire on the Recognition and Enforcement

of Foreign Civil Protection Orders. Prel. Doc. n. 4A of

November 2012. Disponível em

net/index_en.php?act=progress.listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Questionnaire on the recognition and enforcement of

foreign civil protection orders: Summary of Member responses

and possible ways forward. Prel. Doc. n. 4B, of March

Disponível em:

wop/genaff2013pd04b_en.pdf>.

HCCH. Reflection paper to assist in the preparation of a

convention on Jurisdiction and recognition and enforcement of

foreign judgments in civil and commercial matters. Prepared

by Andrea Schulz. Prel. Doc. n. 19, of August 2002.

Disponível em:

jdgm_pd19e.pdf>.

HCCH. Review of the activities of the Conference in regard to

the Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. Rel. Doc. n.

, of March 2011. Disponível em

net/index_en.php?act=progress.listing&cat=5>.

HCCH. Review of the activities of the Conference in regard to

the Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. Prel. Doc. n.

, of March 2011. Disponível em

net/upload/wop/genaff2011pd12e.pdf>.

HCCH. Review of the activities of the Conference in regard to

the Convention on Court Agreements. Prel. Doc. n. 12, of

March 2011. Disponível em:

upload/wop/genaff2011pd12e.pdf>.

HCCH. Some reflections of the Permanent Bureau on a general

convention on enforcement of judgments. Prel. Doc. n. 17 of

May 1992 (in Proceedings of the Seventeenth Session v. 1, p.

, 1993.

HCCH. Some reflections on the present state of negotiations

on the judgment project. Secretariat. Prel. Doc. n 16, of

February 2002. Disponível em:

net/upload/wop/gen_pd16e.pdf>.

HCCH. The relationship between the judgments project and

other international documents. Prepared by Andrea Schulz.

Prel. Doc. n. 24, of December 2003. Disponível em:

pdf>.

KRUEGER, Thalia. The 20th Session of the Hague

Conference: A new choice of court convention and the

issue of EC membership. International and Comparative

Law Quarterly, v. 55, n. 2, p. 447-455, 2006.

MICHAELS, Ralf. Some Fundamental Jurisdictional

Conceptions as Applied in Judgment Conventions.

In: Duke Law School Research Paper, n. 123. Aug. 2006.

Disponível em: .

NYGH, Peter. The Preliminary Draft Hague

Convention on Jurisdiction and Foreign Judgments

in Civil and Commercial Matters. In: BROCHERS,

Patrick J.; ZEKOLL, Joachim (Ed.) International

Conflict of Laws for the Third Millennium: Essays in Honor

of Friedrich K. Juenger. The Hague: Brill, 2001. p.

-270.

OVERBECK, Alfred von. La contribution de la

Conférence de La Haye au développement du Droit

International Prive. Recueil de Cours, v. 233, p. 9-98,

POLIDO, Fabrício B. P. Direito processual internacional

e o contencioso internacional privado. Curitiba: Juruá, 2013.

SCHULZ, Andrea. The Hague Convention of 30

June 2005 on choice of court agreements. Journal of

Private International Law, v. 2, n. 2, p. 243-286, 2006.

TALPIS, Jeffrey; KRNJEVIC, Nick. Hague

Convention on Choice of Court Agreements of June

, 2005: the Elephant That Gave Birth to a Mouse.

The Southwestern Journal of Law & Trade in the Americas,

v. 13, n.1, p.1-33, 2006.

UNITED NATIONS. Division for the Advancement

of Women. Department of Economic and Social

Affairs. UN Handbook for Legislation on Violence Against

Women. New York: United Nations, 2010.

VON MEHREN, Arthur T. Recognition and

Enforcement of Foreign Judgments: A New Approach

for the Hague Conference. Law & Contemporary

Problems, v. 57, p. 271, 1994.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5102/rdi.v11i1.2879

ISSN 2236-997X (impresso) - ISSN 2237-1036 (on-line)

Desenvolvido por:

Logomarca da Lepidus Tecnologia